You mean "Mu Sieiddi Beales Mun Gottan " Firstly it is still there, secondly I (and surprisingly many other rockerrs also) like that song 

But it is also very easy to understand why someone (or most) people don't like it. Usually I request song which I  want to request but that is only song in whole library which I try not to request too much.

Awesome TP! 

The Shaman song is still there and requested on the occasional Friday. I like it.

Silver Bullet - Mooncult

The Witches Hammer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4RFhAwR9kc

Forever Lost
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ia_c5JbgwAs

---

Veonity - Legend of the Starborn

Warrior Of The North
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apsJrPZ9Od8

Rise Again
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnpKN_ojKH4

---

Thornbridge - Theatrical Masterpiece

Theatrical Masterpiece
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QR_EeIM4bFY

Trace of Destruction
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fhp6aaRLJE

---

Deep Sun - Das Erbe der Welt

Abandon Cyberspace
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiXRIUWSS5E

Worship The Warship
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rcjofySzCU

---

Noveria - Aequilibrium

Broken
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUbmnmlWYZs

The Awakening
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QhoQ5p7Kq4

---

This album is not released yet, i hope they will soon.
Some great symphonic powermetal in my opinion.

Memories of Old

The Land Of Xia
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVusSl3RYcc

Zeras Shadow
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0iFawuPj1U

For a while Secret Sphere "Under the Flag of Mary Read" was requested pretty often. Threshold "Pilot in the Sky of Dreams" , Haggard's "Awakening the Centuries (ALL the time when I first joined), Cryonic Temple's "Beastslayer", Savatage "Morphine Child" (one person in particular), Delain, "The Gathering", and worst of all, SAM (and one or two trolls) used to throw in that godforsaken 18+ minute song by Finland Shaman!! I can't remember the name of that damned abomination since it was mercifully removed years ago, but it made me want to die!  Ahhhh, the good ol' days.

Indeed, those are the kind of songs I was thinking of!

Of course with the footnote that the people around now would consider them classics. Betrayal on the Spanish Main would be on the list if it was available for requests.

I'll have to record myself singing it.   

Only the old timers could do this, but we should also have honorable mentions for former ERR Classics as well:

For example, for over a year, Damnation Angels song "Pride [The Warrior's Way]" was played every time it was available to request.  Even further back, before we banned them from the station, Glorious Janitor's "Betrayal on the Spanish Main" was pretty much ERR's theme song.

But see, that's the point. When Savatage and Candlemass have lots of candidates that means no single song is played extremely often. They're just popular songs from popular bands. I considered songs from both bands actually, but decided not to include them because there's no single standout song. It's Savatage playing and the song is When the Crowds are Gone, Edge of Thorns, Gutter Ballet, Hall of the Mountain King or even something else, it's not a specific song playing and "oh yeah it's from Savatage".

Also Octavarium isn't played that often compared to other Dream Theater songs; I'd say Home is a better candidate, for example. EDIT: Okay okay, I have added it.

(also note that it's not about favorite songs, it's about songs that are played often and/or stand out a lot, the kind of song that gets noticed specifically as that one song that plays often)

Not sure about Painkiller. I think there is no single favourite priest song.

But how could you forget:
Dream Theater - Octavarium

also Savatage  & Candlemass have lots of candidates

And all songs about unicorns of course